Nesta report attacks 'miserable' climate change campaigns

by Nikki Sandison, Brand Republic 25-Jun-08, 08:30

LONDON - Government ad campaigns on climate will fail to work unless they stop using 'miserable, gloomy and bleak' imagery, according to a report.

The report, by the National Endowment for Science, Technology and the Arts, claims that government campaigns should instead start encouraging more people to take positive action.

It claims that harnessing commercial-style advertising and marketing techniques would make a powerful impact on changing the behaviour of individuals in response to the threat of climate change.

Called 'Selling Sustainability - Seven Lessons from Advertising and Marketing to Sell Low Carbon Living', the report argues that while UK policy has responded to some degree to the threat of climate change, the government has not yet fully embraced the importance of mass behaviour change to respond to it.

Despite increasing efforts to engage the public on climate change and link it to their individual behaviour, there is little evidence of significant behaviour change to reduce emissions.

The main findings of the report show that as well as avoiding being miserable, campaigns should emphasise that taking action on climate change is normal.

The research, which looked into the effectiveness of advertising on individual behaviour, also suggests that campaigns should recognise the importance of fairness -- everyone needs to be seen to be doing their bit including government and industry.

Nesta said that campaigns should be personally relevant relating to "our" environment not "the" environment and should use insight from commercial ads to engage emotional responses.

Nesta cites Honda's TV ad "Hate something - change something" as a good example of an effective campaign.

One example of current gloomy government environmental advertising is the Department for Environment, Food and Rural Affairs' 'Act On CO2' TV ad campaign, which shows people going about their daily lives leaving visible black carbon footprints.

The report also recommends identifying the potential benefits for individuals by taking action as the basis for a social marketing campaign, citing consumer research that shows millions of people desire a lower-stress, less consumption-oriented lifestyle.

The Nesta report reveals a set of core principles which it strongly recommends should be used for any future campaigns called "The 7Cs". Ads should be clear, compelling, connected, creative, configured, consistent and confident.

Jonathan Kestenbaum, Nesta CEO, said: "The report shows that it's not enough to simply make people aware of climate change issues. To have a mass impact, campaigns must engage people in a compelling way and persuade them to change their behaviour."

Nesta commissioned the British Market Research Bureau to conduct the research.

Comments

John Bunyard

John Bunyard - 25/06/2008

Hmm... ‘creating mass behaviour change’ by persuasion rather presupposes that the people you want to change accept that something needs changing. It doesn’t help that, in HSBC’s Climate Confidence Study, only 22% of Britons polled thought climate change a big deal (cf China 47%, India 60%). In an experiment we conducted recently on ‘An Inconvenient Truth’, measuring among other things arousal levels, the scene highlighting the escalation of CO2 levels (negative) was actually far more affecting than the montage of practical ways of tackling climate change (positive). Something different is needed, that’s for sure; but too much effort has been squandered already on the ’fifties assumption that people will do the right thing if only one can only get the right message across. You’ve only to surf the net to see how often the ‘effective’ message for changing public behaviour turns out the wrong one.

 
 
 
Paul Lawson

Paul Lawson - 26/06/2008

Dear Nikki - Just to leap straight to the heart of the periphery, why have you used a visual of our cheerful, sunny and positive DfT Climate Change ad to illustrate an article about miserable, gloomy and bleak imagery? It's just that sort of ill-thought through stuff that makes us happy clappy people at Leo Burnett really really depressed...

 
 
 
Dan Williamson

Dan Williamson - 30/06/2008

Blatant plug here, but we've just tackled this subject in our latest corporate magazine. Advice on how to approach green campaigns: http://www.cimex.com/business-government/insight/can-going-green-help-avoid-a-downturn/

 
 
 

Have your say

Only registered users may comment. Log in now or register for a free account.

* This information is required.

*
*

Forgotten password?

 

Jobs

Directory