BBC in fresh storm as 517 complain about Clarkson's lorry driver joke

by Jacquie Bowser, Brand Republic 04-Nov-08, 09:05

LONDON - TV presenter Jeremy Clarkson has landed the BBC in hot water again after joking on 'Top Gear' that truck drivers have a hard job "driving and murdering prostitutes".

The BBC has received 517 complaints since the show aired on Sunday, which featured Clarkson and his co-presenters Richard Hammond and James May completing a set of tasks in HGVs.

As Clarkson drove one of the HGVs, he said to the camera: "What matters to lorry drivers? Murdering prostitutes? Fuel economy?

"It's a hard job and I'm not just saying that to gain favour with truck drivers. There's so much to do.

"You've got to change gear, change gear, change gear, check mirror... murder a prostitute. Change gear, change gear, murder."

His remarks were an apparent reference to the Yorkshire Ripper Peter Sutcliffe, a lorry driver, and Suffolk Strangler Steve Wright, who was a former forklift truck driver.

A BBC spokesperson said: "The vast majority of 'Top Gear' viewers have clear expectations of Jeremy Clarkson's long-established and frequently provocative on-screen persona.

"This particular reference was used to comically exaggerate and make ridiculous an unfair urban myth about the world of lorry driving, and was not intended to cause offence."

The joke was not received well by some lorry drivers, including Roger King, chief of the Road Haulage Association.

King wrote to the BBC: "While this could be interpreted as being 'humorous', it certainly is not seen that way by over half a million lorry drivers."

However, one of the UK's biggest haulage firms, the Eddie Stobart group, threw its support behind Clarkson.

Andrew Tinkler, chief executive of the group, said: "They were just having a laugh. It's the 21st century, let's get our sense of humour in line."

Will Shiers, the editor of Truck & Driver magazine, also came out in support of Clarkson. 

Shiers said: "[The] bulk of the UK's drivers who saw the programme loved it. Yes, a small number of drivers were offended by the murdering prostitute reference, but they really are in the minority. 

"On the whole I thought the show was really entertaining. If anything it succeeded in demonstrating to car drivers just how difficult it is to drive a truck."

Ofcom said it had received complaints and was "looking into" the incident but that it had not launched an investigation.

The TV watchdog could not verify the number of complaints it had received.

During the 'Top Gear' episode on Sunday, Clarkson drove his HGV through a brick wall at about 90km/h to complete one of the set tasks.

Clarkson's cab crumpled as the truck hit the brick wall, leaving him with a heavily bruised shin and back, and an index finger that looked like "a burst sausage".

These fresh complaints come just days after the BBC was forced to discipline Jonathan Ross for the lewd phone calls he and comedian Russell Brand made to 'Fawlty Towers' actor Andrew Sachs.

Brand resigned from his BBC Radio 2 show early last week, while Ross was suspended without pay for 12 weeks, taking a £1.3m chunk out of his £6m per-year pay packet.

Lesley Douglas, the BBC Radio 2 controller, also resigned as a result of the incident.

Comments

JT

JT - 04/11/2008

Lorry drivers should strap a pair on. If a similar joke was aimed at, say, waiters and waitresses then they'd laugh too. These things come and go around - it's called humour and it's a good quality to have a sense of it. To complain, if you ask me, only shows their insecurity.

 
 
 
 INGALL

INGALL - 04/11/2008

This is getting ridiculous. Have these people got nothing better to do. If you don't like it. don't watch! If we all allow this tiny minority of idots to dictate what should or should not be shown then we'd all have to watch re-runs of Tales by the riverbank all day long.

 
 
 
r hopkins

r hopkins - 04/11/2008

If anything, this particular show highlighted how dangerous going near these lorries are. I have yet to take over a lorry since seeing this show! It was purely 'fun' and a great watch, We all know Clarkson is not 'PC' ?

 
 
 
joe woollen

joe woollen - 04/11/2008

We're in danger of losing the plot!

 
 
 
Jonathan Godson

Jonathan Godson - 04/11/2008

Typical Clarkson always going for cheap laughs at the expense of others. Sure it can sometimes be funny but referencing the most heinous crime against people in fallen circumstances seems like a cheap shot to me....however I didn't see the programme so look at me writing in....what do I know?!

 
 
 
Michael Laws

Michael Laws - 04/11/2008

I'm sure most of these lorry drivers are not shy of a bit of robust humour - or am I stereotyping again \(waiting for the avalanche of complaints) I don't really watch top gear and think clarkson is a bit of an idiot, but I did see this particular show and the joke was actually quite funny... Eddie Stobart CEO was spot on.

 
 
 
Gordon Macmillan

Gordon Macmillan - 04/11/2008

It was very funny, but killing hookers was maybe in dubious taste.

 
 
 
Michael Laws

Michael Laws - 04/11/2008

bad taste humouor is normally the best sort - if they put a stop to that, we british won't have much left to laugh at.

 
 
 
marcus evans

marcus evans - 04/11/2008

Has anyone even thought about this from the perspective of the prostitues?

 
 
 
 Phil Berry

Phil Berry - 04/11/2008

500k truckers : 2 murderers 235m global viewers : 188 complaints \(2.4m : 2) Well by the ratio you are more likely... Clarkson takes the p... out of everyone - thus the viewing figures. Every other week he has a go at us bikers but any complaints? If anything it proved how difficult the trucker's job is - if the 188 missed this point clearly they weren't watching the same show.

 
 
 
Matt Saunders

Matt Saunders - 04/11/2008

The Internet has made it much easier for people to complain, and those Computer User supplements in the Mail on Sunday aren't helping...

 
 
 
Carl Martin

Carl Martin - 04/11/2008

I think there is an important issue arising from this recent spate of 'constant-complaining'. Todays audiences have become increasingly dumbed down to drugs, murder, blood, guts, sex and much more; rendering it acceptable through the appropriate and expected channels, however because a pubclic broadcaster is employing the same mould, the small minority of serial 'moaners' feel it only appropriate to stand up for their views. No problems there, however when household names such as Ross, Brand and now Clarkson are involved, people need to accept that these people are famous for their personality, sense of humour and attitude towards life and current affairs. If you don't like it, don't watch it! I would put money on 90% of those who complained this time having nothing to do with Lorrys, Haulage or transport. Are todays audience given too much freedom of expression? Is there such thing as too much freedom of expression?

 
 
 
Morley#99

Morley#99 - 04/11/2008

To be honest I'm a still a bit stunned that there is only 500-odd complaints..... lets face it there are more people that watch the program just to be outraged by it so they can complain and therefore give their pathetic lives some sort of justification!

 
 
 
James Wilkinson

James Wilkinson - 04/11/2008

what is this World coming to! i am worried for the future of the british broadcast system!

 
 
 
Rick Wilks

Rick Wilks - 05/11/2008

Get a life you pathetic low lives clarkson is a legend. now thats off my chest there is currently a petition online to replace the the bbc motogp commentery team with over 5000 signitures what are the bbc doing about that...!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!

 
 
 

Have your say

Only registered users may comment. Log in now or register for a free account.

* This information is required.

*
*

Forgotten password?

 

Jobs

Directory