Skinny models don't necessarily sell more products

by Staff, Brand Republic 17-Nov-08, 09:15

SYDNEY - Advertising that uses super-thin models does not make women more likely to buy products than ads featuring women who are of a more healthy weight, according to research by an Australian academic.

Do skinny models sell more products? **Vote** and have your say in our poll.

Phillippa Diedrichs, of the University of Queensland, created a series of ads for underwear, a haircare product and a party dress.

Each ad was made twice, once using a size eight model and the other featuring a size 12 model.

The Sydney Morning Herald reports that when Diedrichs showed the ads to 400 young people, she found no difference in the likelihood of respondents buying the advertised products depending on whether they had seen the skinnier ad or the one showing the bigger woman.

She did report, however, that women aged between 18 and 25 felt better about their own body image if they had viewed the images of the larger models than those shown the thinner women.

She told the SMH: "For anything to change, research has to be convincing not just to government and health researchers but also to people in advertising who actually make the decisions. Often people make the argument that thinness sells, and that's why they use [slim models]."

Unilever brand Dove has also made a big deal of its campaign using "real women" and highlighting how much imagery in advertising is manipulated.

The company has subsequently been criticised for using more traditional imagery to promote other brands, such as Lynx/Axe deodorant, which feature a succession of skinny models.

There have been concerted campaigns to cut back on the use of ultra-thin "size zero" models, with fashion weeks in Madrid and Milan attempting to ensure that all the models appearing on the catwalk are of a weight that is deemed healthy by the Body Mass Index measure.

However, fashion editors maintain that they must use thin models because clothing companies supply samples in small sizes.

Comments

John Bunyard

John Bunyard - 17/11/2008

Sounds a bit dubious to me - stated intention to purchase is notoriously unreliable. We've done an experiment in which people plainly didn't know their own preference even after they'd taken action!

 
 
 
Nicola Lucas

Nicola Lucas - 18/11/2008

The size 12 does look better but I don't know how would effect my buying habits. Probably wouldn't make a difference actually, which means the person was right.

 
 
 
Dominic Gudgeon

Dominic Gudgeon - 19/11/2008

If it doesn't make a difference, what's the problem?

 
 
 
Gonca Telli Yamamoto

Gonca Telli Yamamoto - 21/11/2008

If it is underware why not? If the product is a car, probably. If the product is a biscuit it depends on the buyer. If the product is a diet book, yes. If theproduct is a computer probably not.......

 
 
 

Have your say

Only registered users may comment. Log in now or register for a free account.

* This information is required.

*
*

Forgotten password?

 

Jobs

Directory