Brand Republic
 
Edition:
UK |
Asia
 
Digital jobs

Jobs

Directory

 

Understanding why we shouldn't advertising on the Web!

Last post 20 May 2008 1:21 PM by Sunny Soomal. 18 replies.
Sort Posts:
1 2  next
  • 24 May 2007 9:14 AM

    Understanding why we shouldn't advertising on the Web!

    The Internet is part of a revolution that is causing business a lot of headaches. With its networked communities, based on trust and candour together with a huge contempt for corporate smugness.

    The fact of the matter is that assumptions about consumer behaviour never related to how people lived their lives.

    However corporate greed is now busily investing huge amounts of money in the Internet; Microsoft $6 billion, Google $3 billion, WPP $650 million, all in the space of a few weeks.

    Their return will come through eyeballs, get enough eyeballs, shown them enough advertisements, and that will make nice profits for everybody involved.

    In the past this formulae has produced a ton of money. However we have paid a price, it has produced television programming where one programme is indistinguishable from everything else together with a rising blizzard of commercials – called clutter!

    Nowadays however we do have a choice, the Internet. And people, you, me and the guy around the corner, having been treated for so long as mere eyeballs, are moving to the Internet in our millions.

    We have no loyalty whatsoever to the Old Media, who, together with their handmaidens, The Advertising Agencies, have treated us with contempt, as nothing more than demographics, dehumanising and depersonalising us in their rush to get their hands on all those lovely advertising big bucks!

    Initially marketing ignored the net, then they had an awakening, and are now rushing headlong onto the Web thinking that this is the New Medium.

    As a result Corporations, ably aided by their minions, the Advertising Agencies, are treating the Internet as a source of a mass market – which it isn't!

    Frankly people go on line on their way to going elsewhere, and most people are looking for (dirty) pictures; jokes and the latest home made video joke – they certainly do not want to look at advertisements!

    And what do Google and Microsoft and WPP want?

    They want to deliver advertising to you – as much as possible because it is worth a bucketload of money to them. The Google, Microsoft, WPP investments represent the ultimate goal of mass Media and mass Marketing, they want to become as big as possible so that they can tie up the mass market! Because all they care about is making more money for their investors.

    We must never forget that Mass Media existed to serve the marketing needs of Corporations – the Net was never created for that purpose.

    Because Mass Marketing has never, for once, treated the consumer as an individual, and because of this, have practically ruined our perfectly good media system. The needs of advertising agencies are dictating that we neglect a perfectly good media environment and move elsewhere – well advertising is not working now and it will never work on the Web!

    So perhaps, for once, Google, Microsoft and WPP have got it all wrong. the internet takes to advertising like a fish out of water!

    Sadly however, marketing and advertising executives regard us as fools! For years they have become used to preparing ads, and sponsoring programmes that fit all their pie charts.

    But their simplistic formulae's will not replicate on the Web, how do you, after all, sell advertising to billions of sources each with a handful of viewers?

     

     

  • 25 May 2007 12:38 AM

    RE: Understanding why we shouldn't advertising on the Web!

    Think my dissertation title for next year might be a bit interesting then...

    'To what exent is the online environment being adopted by the advertising industry as the most effective branding tool'

    I would note at this point that this is merely a draft title and is likely to be changed as I haven't even started my disseration yet!

  • 25 May 2007 1:24 PM

    RE: Understanding why we shouldn't advertising on the Web!

    Thank you for your comments...may I make a suggestion?   I really think that we all need to revisit the word "communication" as we have lost sight as to the real meaning of the word.With a more perfect understanding of communication all our problems will disappear, the rising blizzard of clutter; the decline in television audience, the total lack of accountability,

    I really believe that we must return to properly understanding the word communication!

     

  • 25 May 2007 4:29 PM

    RE: Understanding why we shouldn't advertising on the Web!

    Lovely stuff but I fear it is fundamentally flawed

    Here is your clue....

    CONVERGENCE

  • 29 May 2007 11:11 AM

    RE: Understanding why we shouldn't advertising on the Web!

    Convergence has nothing to do with communication....hmmm...who's flawed here?
  • 29 May 2007 1:43 PM

    RE: RE: Understanding why we shouldn't advertising on the Web!

    It has EVERYTHING to do with communication as it is the coming together of ALL COMMUNICATIONS CHANNELS INTO ONE
  • 30 May 2007 12:33 PM

    RE: Understanding why we shouldn't advertising on the Web!

    So let me get this right. So you're saying that because the internet is made up of millions of sites and some attract 'handfuls of visitors' that the entire medium isn't worth bothering with? Yes there are niche sites, but they attract niche advertisers.

    I can think of countless verticals that deliver results for clients. And Google's got rich off small businesses finally finding a medium they can afford to advertise on.

    As for the 'mass market', there are many sites that I'd count as mass. YouTube, Facebook, The Guardian... the list goes on. The medium's targettable, measurable, interactive and good value for money.

  • 30 May 2007 1:47 PM

    RE: Understanding why we shouldn't advertising on the Web!

    ALL YOUR ADS R BELONG TO US.
  • 30 May 2007 2:53 PM

    RE: Understanding why we shouldn't advertising on the Web!

    Couldn't have said it better myself :-)
  • 01 Jun 2007 10:57 AM

    RE: Understanding why we shouldn't advertising on the Web!

    ends up as a bit of a rant against Ad Agencies doesn't it Paul? Actually it's the digital agencies that are pushing the big corporations into understanding what the web 2.0 concept can do for them and how to build great interactive ads that do engage people and create that elusive brand affinity that will lead to a more profitable relationship between advertiser and consumer.

    Once we all understand when people are responsive to online advertising (i.e. when they are open to being distracted from the reason they went online in the first place) and design the media plan, creative and message to tune into this then online advertising will be more acceptable to the users and more effective for the advertisers.

  • 05 Jun 2007 5:39 PM

    RE: Understanding why we shouldn't advertising on the Web!

    So, let me clarify what you are saying... Online advertising doesn't work? So how come Google has become one of the most powerful technology/media co's on the planet on the back of delivering the most efficient direct response ROI generating model in existence.....It goes something like this. Put £1 in, £2.50 comes out.....

    You may not have noticed, but quite a few people use the internet to research, share opinions (as we are doing), buy stuff, etc. I'd say most consumers would rather be shown relevant ads in these contexts, than in many other media channels.  Especially if the ads support free content...or would you rather pay for your dirty pics, jokes and comedy video clips?

     

  • 12 Jan 2008 12:42 PM

    RE: Understanding why we shouldn't advertising on the Web!

    'Clutter' is the keyword isn't it? Do B2C sites really think that ads taking over one quarter of the page are going to get our attention. We don't have time for annoying things full stop.

    It seems that simple ads do get better click throughs than animated or over-complicated ads. I work on a number of sites for clients on a B2B level and some of them don't even bother to look at clicks any more - the ad for them is all about branding. However, a call to action on another format brings in a 2% CTR for another advertiser and they send out 150 brouchures per month as a result. What's more, they tell us they've had sales from it.

    So, is all online advertising a waste of time, no. Is most online advertising a waste of time, possibly.

    I think media owners and online publishers have to come up with packages that can do different jobs. It is not all about clicks - it should be about giving people clicks, awareness, sales leads and more. 

    There is no doubt that people are switching off to 'fussy' and 'clutter' but it's not all bad news.

    Web Advertising

  • 21 Feb 2008 8:31 PM

    RE: Understanding why we shouldn't advertising on the Web!

    Forget On line, forget digital, and concentrate on Communication!

    More and more evidence, rather like a bad penny, keeps turning up that supports my original contention that advertising on the Internet is a complete waste of money.
    Consider this:
    99% of Web users do not click on ads on a monthly basis.  Of the 1% that do, most only click once a month.
    Then consider this:
    “Users become more or less desensitised to the advertising” says the President of video game publisher Green Screen, “You won’t make money on it.”
    Then consider:
    65% of all Web visitors log on to visit pornography!   Are they worth advertising to? Hmmm maybe for condoms, not much else though – and even then will they be interested enough to watch commercials?
    Then consider:
    “There’s too much (advertising) when you sign on,” complains MySpace user John Sigona (32) who likes the site but ignores the ads.    “They don’t interest me,” he claims
    Then there’s this to consider:
    Heavy clickers represent just 6% of the on line population yet account for 50% of all display ad clicks.  Yet heavy clickers are not representative of the general public
    It appears pretty conclusive to me that combining this information with banner blindness, that things don’t look good for online display advertising!
    Which, when you consider reality (not advertising reality I hasten to add!) is not all that surprising.
    We really must get on with developing relevant, engaging advertising, by that I mean not passive one-way advertising – but properly executed interactive advertising!

  • 21 Feb 2008 8:36 PM

    RE: RE: RE: Understanding why we shouldn't advertising on the Web!

    UTTER NONSENSE...laddie before you start talking about convergence and communication please read a dictionary and understand the meaning of both words.    I repeat, CONVERGENCE HAS NOTHING AT ALL TO DO WITH COMMUNICATION...
  • 05 Mar 2008 2:57 PM

    RE: Understanding why we shouldn't advertising on the Web!

    I Agree advertising on the web isn’t very good

    I mean how needs measurable results, targeted messages, and effective pricing models?

    Search marketing is growing at a tremendous rate providing organisations small and large with an opportunity to attract our attention. 

    My only concern is social networking sites and larger companies shoehorning traditional techniques to fit. This is the next online challenge and money making opportunity, how to fit adverts into this arena.

Page 1 of 2 (19 items)
1 2  next